Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie

For Kenny’s 31st Birthday I made him a Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie because he loves Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. He also is not a huge fan of cake so I knew there was not point in me even making him a cake. My friend Kimberly sent me her Peanut Butter Pie recipe, but I wanted to make it more chocolaty (probably not a word). That way is would taste more like a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup. Let me just tell you it is amazing! Kenny had to keep himself from eating the whole pie because he knew it would make him go into a sugar coma and probably end up sick! First I made an Oreo Crust, using the recipe below.

Reese's Peanut Butter Pie

Oreo Crust


24 Oreo Cookies

1/3 Cup Butter


Crush the Oreos. You can do them more fine to get a smoother crust. I left them a little chunky because I like the crust to be thicker.

Melt the butter then slowly add it in with the Oreos. I did a little at the time and stirred around until I got the consistency I wanted.

Put the Oreo Mixture into a pie pan. I only pressed it on the bottom of the pan, not the sides. Again because I like a thick crust.

Then I put the crust in the fridge while I made the filling. Just so the crust would cool down and harden a little.

Reese's Peanut Butter Pie

Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie


1- 80z. Cream Cheese Package

1/4 Cup Peanut Butter

1/4 Cup Chocolate Peanut Butter

1 Cup Powdered Sugar

1- 8oz. Cool Whip Tub

25 Mini Reese’s Cups

1 Oreo Pie Crust

Reese's Peanut Butter Pie

Cream together the Peanut Butters and Cream Cheese.

Mix in the Powders and the Cool Whip. Until smooth.

Chop up about most of the Reese’s Cups. Gently stir into mixture.

Pour into the Oreo Pie Crust. Cut the other Reese’s Cups up and place on top. Chill.

  DSC_6251 copy

Hope you enjoy this Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie recipe. It was very easy to make and would make a great surprise for your Valentine!


    Leave a Reply

    Current day month ye@r *

  1. Leah Lucas says:

    I was reading this recipe to my family tonight and they are telling me that I am making this tomorrow! So, I guess I have some groceries to buy! Luckily, this sounds super easy! And delicious!

  2. Oh YUM! That looks delicious.

  3. Thanks a lot for sharing this. I would love to try this soonest :)

  4. Girl…this looks SO yummy! OMG. :-)

  5. This would be nice to serve someone for their birthday.

  6. Sweta Sonulkar says:

    Looks yummy and delicious and would love to try this recipe

  7. Dorothy Teel says:

    Wow this sounds great and I love Reeses Peanut butter cups, I am afraid I am a little like you hubby and would try to eat it all. Thank you for the time it took to share this with the rest of us and coming up with such a great idea.

  8. Emma Brown says:

    Omg! This is heaven.I want it now. :D

  9. This looks so incredibly scrumptious!!

  10. Oh how yummie! And the photos are beautiful; have a real vintage feel to them. Something very homely and comforting about the pie and the photos too.

  11. eleonor says:

    saves the recipe. this looks yummy

  12. So the rumors are true! This looks absolutely delicious, thank you for sharing!

  13. Dorothy Boucher says:

    this sounds so yummy, who doesn’t love a good reese’s peanut butter cup, and a huge one at that loll , love the recipe and thanks for share @tisonlyme143

  14. Oh my gosh this look so sinful! Good thing birthdays only come once a year! But of course there’s national peanut butter day, national chocolate day, etc ;-)

  15. Judy Thomas says:

    OMG! Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are not that easy to come by in New Zealand but I have pinned this to my Pinterest so that I can make it on a special occasion :) Thank you.YUM!

  16. Oh my! I’m definitely pinning this now! That pie looks so amazing! Thanks for sharing this.

  17. This looks amazing! My other half loves peanut butter so I’m going to make this for him next time I’m in the mood for baking. I’ll have to substitute some of the ingredients as I don’t think they’re available in the UK, but I’m sure it will be fine. Thanks for sharing this great recipe!

  18. Jenn Oldaker says:

    OMG my hubby would DIE for this lol! Too bad I didn’t stumble on this post a tad sooner… that could’ve been his valentine’s day treat :) I love reese’s too ….. but he’s a HUGE PB fan!

  19. That looks heavenly! I am a big fan of Reeses!

  20. Omg..yummy!

  21. that looks delicous

  22. Wow this looks so good, thank you for sharing!

  23. john hutchens says:

    Thanks for the recipe. I love Reeses , gonna give this a try and I like that it is easy to make

  24. RICHARD HICKS says:

    Reeses are my favorite candy. Got to make this pie soon! Looks so tasty!

  25. Yum! It looks so good! I may have to try adding the chocolate next time! :)